Sunday 22 November 2026

Harsh decisions need to be made for the greater good

This article first appeared in Malta Today

I have long concluded that logic is not our strong point as a nation.

According to the latest Budget Barometer by Esprimi (a Maltese research company) which questioned a sample of 400 Maltese adults, “Maltese citizens overwhelmingly want Malta to depend less on non-EU workers, but reject almost every consequence that reduction would entail.”

Of those who agreed Malta should rely less on non-EU workers, 84% opposed fewer places available in care home , 82% opposed reduced bus services, 75% opposed delays in construction, and 73% opposed longer hospital waits. The opposition to losing taxis (56%) and restaurants (58%) was slightly lower.

What does this tell us? Well, what comes to mind is a colloquial expression which fits this attitude perfectly: “irriduha ħobla u tredda”, which literally means, we want someone to be pregnant and breastfeeding at the same time. In other words, wanting two things at once which cannot realistically happen simultaneously; it’s either one or the other. In English we would say “wanting to have your cake and eat it too”, although many feel that the whole point of having a cake is to eat it, so our Maltese idiom is arguably more precise.

When I read the proliferation of comments online, the general misguided belief across the board is that certain actions can be taken without any consequences. It’s like we expect a fairy godmother to sprinkle magic dust and make all the bad things go away so that we can go to the ball and marry the prince. As I was trying to trace back how we became so unreasonable and petulant, I came across an excellent analysis of the debate held between two past Prime Ministers, Lawrence Gonzi and Alfred Sant, which was organised by The Times. Written by Simon Azzopardi it perfectly pointed out that what we have lost are these type of principled politicians, both of whom were willing to risk their careers by making unpopular but vital decisions for the greater good. To quote Azzopardi:

“In 2006, Gonzi’s government raised the pension age to 65 for men and women alike and lengthened the contribution period. Everyone serious knew it had to be done. Nobody was going to thank him for doing it. Add the privatisation of the shipyards, and you have two reforms that proved deeply unpopular. In 2013, his party lost the election and he resigned. He paid.
Sant paid too, and quickly. In 1996 he came to power, after dragging a party still living in Mintoff’s shadow into the modern era. By 1998, governing on a one-seat majority, he faced open revolt from Dom Mintoff, his party’s former leader and by then a backbencher, over the Cottonera marina project. Sant could have negotiated and kept his job. Instead, he tied the vote to his own political future. Mintoff voted against, the government fell, and Sant lost the early election that followed. You can call it a misjudgement, and many did. But you can’t call it spineless.”

In contrast, what we have today is an administration which doesn’t dare upset the Maltese because they have become spoiled with the Budget always being like Christmas and their birthday rolled into one. Just look at the fuss being kicked up by air b ‘n’ b owners because the steep hike in the eco tax is affecting their bookings. PM Robert Abela probably knows deep down that he might eventually need to take some harsh decisions but he also knows that his once faithful supporters would turn on him like Rottweilers if he so much as touches anything which is currently free (childcare, buses, exams, school transport etc). Students’ stipends? There would be riots. Fuel subsidies? They would go after him with pitchforks. So for now he is stalling, desperately instructing his Finance Minister to tax everyone except locals, because he needs to keep up the pretence that everything is fine, just fine.

In fact, Abela’s reference to European colleagues in Dublin being “stunned by Malta’s economic success” is a perfect illustration of this delusion. In his eagerness to brag about what Malta has managed to do, he neglected to say that all this has come at an unquantifiable cost to the Maltese people. I wonder if he happened to mention that this accelerated economic growth was only made possible by shredding Malta’s identity to pieces, which started with the selling of our citizenship, then stripping the authenticity of its towns and villages through over-development and saturating the island with mass tourism which depends on a mostly foreign workforce as its front-of-staff. We were not satisfied with our previous tourist arrivals but wanted to shoot higher and go for millions and millions – the result is more hotels, malls and franchises but not enough Maltese employees to man them.

The price we have paid and are still paying is the foreign “invasion” which bothers so many people who are simultaneously reluctant to give up their current lifestyle. In a nutshell, that is what it boils down to…are we willing to give up our comforts along with crucial services which are only possible because there is an endless supply of economic migrants? We have trapped ourselves into a corner because no one had the balls to take difficult, admittedly harsh decisions.

Instead, for the last 13 years we have been mollycoddled, cushioned, pampered and protected in a way which has done more harm than good. It has kept Labour consistently popular because dishing out free money is great for instant gratification but, as the saying goes, there is no such thing as a free lunch and there are always strings attached. Those strings, in case you still haven’t figured it out, have entangled this country into a web which is so reliant on foreign employees that many have over-extended themselves in their scramble to cash in. They have taken out loans to open businesses and to buy flats as a rental investment because they know there is a steady stream of people who have money to spend and who need accommodation.

The alternative, of course, which so many keep claiming they want, is to hit the brakes and reverse this dependence on foreign nationalities who are keeping the economic motor running. But once we start to examine that scenario it is obvious that something will have to give. Maybe there should be another survey which asks two simple questions: what would you prefer (a) the same benefits, freebies, subsidies but over-population or (b) a reduced population but more taxes. I trust no one is under any illusion that there will be no repercussions.

The failure of Clyde Caruana to go public with his 2017 report, which predicted all this but which was shelved, is frankly another example of a politician who is out to save his own skin. He pocketed a hefty payment of 90k for something we could have all told him for free – increasing the population by importing people to work in all our various sectors will lead to an economic boom but it will also create a multitude of other problems as a result. He has now promised to publish the report, to tell us what we already know.

Apart from the inability to join the dots and come to a logical conclusion, there is another aspect of this issue which continues to irk me. That is the fake patriotism and the absurd accusation that by denouncing discrimination against others, we are being racist against our own. Please spare me all this empty rhetoric. If everyone loves Malta so much why are so many willing to sell their family home to greedy developers who have ruined the landscape of every town/village by building ugly blocks of soulless flats? And why aren’t owners ready to sell or rent a flat at a decent price to the Maltese instead? I find the beating of chests quickly fades when there is a quick buck to be made.

The resentment against non-EU nationals is also laced with so much hypocrisy; I wonder if all these people who hate them with such venom are the same ones who are happy to charge them exorbitant rents or who are exploiting them by paying them the bare minimum? I think we need to take a long, hard look in the mirror and ask ourselves what we really want, what kind of trade offs we are willing to make and what we would be happy to give up.

The government likewise needs to start being realistic and rip the band aid off, because sooner or later it has to be honest with the nation about the country’s fiscal and socio-economic predicament.

Powered By9H Digital